IN THE BEDROOM (2001)
A New England couple's college-aged son dates an older woman who has two small children and an unwelcome ex-husband.

A New England couple's college-aged son dates an older woman who has two small children and an unwelcome ex-husband.

The little details reign supreme in Todd Field’s directorial debut, In the Bedroom, in which three good people are driven to despair and torment after the death of a loved one. In the aftermath of this unimaginable tragedy, the landscape of their emotional lives seems flattened to a line of sorrow. Married couple Ruth (Sissy Spacek) and Matt Fowler (Tom Wilkinson) find themselves focusing on minor visual and aural cues. Matt can’t shut out the sound of coins clinking in the family lawyer’s wallet as he talks about his commitment to the case arising from the film’s central death. Ruth notices that the photographs of loved ones in the lawyer’s office don’t support his claim to understand what the grief-stricken couple are going through.
As Village Voice critic Dennis Lim so aptly put it, In the Bedroom is “a small miracle of patience and composure”. It bides its time, introducing viewers to the peaceful, idyllic coastal town of Camden, where life moves at a gentle pace and people have the time, patience and inclination to sit and talk with their neighbours and loved ones. Nothing dramatic could ever happen in a place like this, the film seems to suggest at every turn — though never in a way that makes you roll your eyes as you anticipate tragedy. It earns its easygoing nature; there’s something earnest in its depiction of tranquillity. If only life could be so simple, you might think. The film is building towards that very thought.

It’s impossible not to suspect that something is awry amid the film’s lethargic plotting. But even as the source of its venom worms its way into the centre of this tragic tale, nothing about the developments feels contrived. The same is true of the way Field establishes these characters and a town that seems to reflect their easygoing personalities. It’s remarkably difficult to create a sense of community on film, especially one that resists the sentimentality that can make characters seem two-dimensional and unrealistically optimistic. It isn’t always clear how Field will anchor these interlinked lives in In the Bedroom, but it’s a pleasure to watch them overlap as you wait for the definitive moment that will change each of them irrevocably.
“Easygoing” isn’t always an apt description of Ruth, who frets over her son Frank’s (Nick Stahl) new girlfriend, Natalie Strout (Marisa Tomei), a mother of two. She’s right to be concerned, given the recurring presence of Natalie’s abusive ex-husband, Richard (William Mapother). But the film also cleverly skewers how loudly classism can speak, even when it’s never openly discussed. It shows in Ruth’s disdain for Natalie, and in the way Matt lives vicariously through his son, admiring his relationship with an older woman who knows far more about romance than he does. Crucially, Field doesn’t disrupt the peaceful rhythms of everyday life. Instead, he plants seeds of these tempestuous ideas just beneath the affable surface of family barbecues and pleasant small talk.
In the Bedroom isn’t essential viewing if you’re looking for a film that leaves you perched on the edge of your seat, desperate to find out how the story will unfold. But it’s a strong debut, guided by a remarkably assured voice. Adapting a roughly 30-page short story — “Killings” by Andre Dubus — into a feature film is no small feat, though Dubus’s stories are often dense even as they move forward with a light touch. They unearth eerie, haunting shivers of doubt in the human spirit as their characters grapple with tragedy. Dubus’s 1989 story “Leslie in California” is just five pages long, yet it captures the mindset of a domestic abuse victim in such raw, poetic terms that it condenses a lifetime of emotion into a lightning-fast read.

It’s in this disquiet that Wilkinson and Spacek shine. Their grief changes them for ever, even as aspects of their former selves cling on for survival. A bitter argument between the pair finally disrupts the calm that has settled over the story from the outset. The camera jolts forward, frantically tracking them through their home. The words they exchange are acidic and awful: the kind of unspoken feelings you half-believe deep down, but which suddenly sound monstrous when said aloud. Worse still, every moment of the exchange contains grains of truth. Field trusts viewers to recognise the humanity running through these scenes. Whether through the devastating performances, the assured direction or the focus on small details, In the Bedroom is at its best when it displays its maturity and tenderness. Fortunately, it has both in abundance.
And yet, for all the praise Field’s debut rightly deserves, the film never stops feeling like a short story stretched to feature length through clever storytelling choices. It feels like a very long short film — and, if you’ll forgive the oddness of that description, this betrays its lack of essential qualities, leaving it riveting in only a handful of sequences. It doesn’t offer a complete emotional journey. The ending lands on precisely the kind of note one might expect from a short story, but still leaves something to be desired in a 131-minute film. Field preserves the essential quality of “Killings” — its blend of warmth and tragedy — and dissects it thoroughly, bringing small details to life with great effect. The overall picture, though, remains less satisfying than it might have been.
USA | 2001 | 131 MINUTES | 2.39:1 | COLOUR | ENGLISH • SERBO-CROATIAN


director: Todd Field.
writers: Todd Field & Robert Festinger (based on the short story ‘Killings’ by Andre Dubus).
starring: Sissy Spacek, Tom Wilkinson, Nick Stahl, William Mapother, William Wise, Celia Weston & Marisa Tomei.
