5 out of 5 stars

The sheer talent of Bette Davis! Her performance was always the selling point of Now, Voyager. Davis’s character, Charlotte Vale, starts the film as a mousy, fat (by Golden Age standards), wild-browed, frump, living her life at the beck and call of her cruel and dominating mother (Gladys Cooper). Much to her aristocratic New England mother’s disdain and inconvenience, Charlotte keeps breaking into prolonged periods of crying. There seems to be something wrong with the poor girl…

Fearing Charlotte’s on the verge of a nervous breakdown, her sister-in-law Lisa (Ilka Chase) brings to the house a renowned psychiatrist called Dr Jaquith (Claude Raines). Jaquith instantly realises Charlotte’s mother’s the cause of her neurosis and recommends she stay at his facility. And so, under Jaquith’s care, Charlotte embarks on a long road to recovery and, at the end of her stay (now thin, plucked, and stylish) she embarks on a cruise to South America. A cruise that’ll change her, and her life, forever…

It’s no surprise to say that Bette Davis is excellent in Now, Voyager. She makes every stage of Charlotte’s transformation both emotionally believable and joyously fantastical. We feel every blow she’s dealt, by her mother and fate, and feel every swell of sympathy and joy she’s given by Jaquith and the man she meets on her cruise: Jerry (Paul Henreid). The latter’s a sympathetic, if simple, man, but Charlotte could do without anything complicated right now…

The real nail-biting tension and jaw-clenching drama come when the new Charlotte returns to the old house, to her old mother, and refuses to take up her old position. Gladys Cooper is squirm-inducingly dislikeable as the matriarchal dictator who’ll brook no dissent and use every available parental power (threatening to cut off allowance) and emotional manipulation (feigning illness) to keep her daughter in line.

Both Raines and Henreid bring natural charm to roles that aren’t as fleshed out or as complex as the main women; and that’s fair enough, as this is a Women’s Picture that passes the Bechdel Test with flying colours. (Both Henreid and Raines would be recompensed on their next project, a little film called Casablanca, which gave them their most iconic and enduring roles).

It’s no insult to say that Now, Voyager is a Women’s Picture, even if the term was coined to be derogative. It was 1942, and Warner Bros. (along with other big studios) noticed there were a lot of men who had a long way to travel if they wanted to see a movie on a Friday night, and a lot of women with the freedom to do what they pleased and see whatever they choose. Regretfully, in the 21st-century, it still feels strange to see a big-budget prestige production that focuses on mostly female experiences. The studios’ solution to the change in demographics was to buy up the rights to novels most women were reading, and then get their almost exclusively male crews to churn out weepies. So what happened to make Now, Voyager so good?

The answer has to be its surprisingly sensitive source material: Olive Higgins Prouty’s 1941 novel, based on her own struggles with mental health and restorative stay at a psychiatric retreat. It was adapted into a fantastic screenplay by Casey Robinson. In fact, Now, Voyager still shines as a beacon of progressive mental health representation. Charlotte isn’t mad or schizophrenic, or dangerous… she’s just beaten down. All she needs is kindness and sympathy. It’s not self-will or manning-up that saves her, it’s understanding: understanding from others, and understanding herself.

Irving Rapper’s direction is also excellent, working in tandem with Sol Polito’s sharp cinematography, Warren Law’s tight editing, Orry-Kerry’s glorious costumes, and Max Steiner’s Academy Award-winning score. One standout example of these filmmaking talents working together in harmony is when Charlotte’s first returned to the crumbling family pile. As she quarrels with her mother about her living arrangements, she disappears around a corner, to change for the evening’s dinner party. The conversation carries on, with just her mother left in the frame (seen from behind) and all attention is drawn to her two claw-like fingers on her left hand as they tap on the bed frame. Both their voices are calm and respectful, and yet her mother’s burning fury is visible in the steady tapping of those elderly digits. The genius of the film is in such little details, and in the physicalisation of repressed emotions—such as the simple, intimate, and still iconic act of lighting two cigarettes.

Now, Voyager is still a weepy at heart, however. Everyone involved works hard to make us care desperately for Charlotte and, as a result, it’s an emotional experience. A great story about someone dealt a bad lot, who gets a chance to make something more of her life. But that’s not the same as saying she can have it all. It has a beautifully sombre conclusion, too, summed up by the iconic final line: “Jerry, don’t let’s ask for the moon. We have the stars.”

frame rated divider criterion

Blu-ray Special Features:

  • New, restored 4K digital transfer, with an uncompressed monaural soundtrack on the Blu-ray. As one would expect from Criterion, this is a flawless print and audio track. The absolutely scratchless restoration alone makes the high price worth it.
  • An episode of The Dick Cavett Show from 1971 featuring actor Bette Davis. A rather random choice, as Now, Voyager is discussed only fleetingly, and the interview is otherwise unexceptional. The extras on Criterion releases do sometimes feel like a lucky dip into the film archives.
  • Interview with actor Paul Henreid from 1980. Another odd choice, a three-minute interview with Henreid pulled from a US magazine show. All discussion is focussed on Casablanca and includes his criticism of a key moment of the film.
  • New selected-scene commentary on the film’s score by scholar Jeff Smith. An interesting demonstration of Steiner’s use of the leitmotif and some biographical information on Steiner. This is probably most useful as a teaching resource for Film Studies classes, but if you’re interested in film scores you will find some value in it.
  • New interview with film critic Farran Smith Nehme on the making of the film. This is the real highlight of the extras, and another example of Criterion paying an intelligent and eloquent expert to talk about the film. As ever, these function like the introduction at the beginning of a special edition of a book, providing you with both a historical context for the film’s production and an overview and analysis of the key technical and thematic elements.
  • New interview with costume historian Larry McQueen. A mildly interesting ten-minute overview of the costumes of Now, Voyager and the career of costume designer Orry-Kerry.
  • Two radio adaptations from 1943 and 1946. The obligatory Lux Radio Theatre adaptations, one featuring Ida Lupino standing in for Bette Davis, and one featuring Gregory Peck standing in for Paul Henreid. Who listens to these things?
  • Plus: An essay by scholar Patricia White and a 1937 reflection on acting by Davis.

frame rated divider

Cast & Crew

director: Irving Rapper.
writer: Casey Robinson (based on the novel by Olive Higgins Prouty).
starring: Bette Davis, Paul Henreid, Claude Rains & Gladys Cooper.